Skip to main content
Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani, LLP. logo.

Washington Administration Code Update: Investigation and Unfair Claims Practices

Effective October 18, 2026, the Washington Office of the Insurance Commissioner (OIC) amended 15 sections of Chapter 284-30 Washington Administrate Code (WAC), affecting how insurers investigate, document, evaluate, and resolve claims.

What Changed?

The following regulations were amended: WAC 284-30-320, -330, -340, -350, -355, -360, -370, -380, -390, -391, -392, -393, -394, and -395. 

The amendments address issues throughout the life of a claim, including:

  • What constitutes a reasonable claim investigation;
  • Use of databases, estimating software, and benchmarks;
  • Claim file documentation and an insured’s access to portions of the claim file;
  • Deadlines for investigations and claim decisions;
  • Communications with claimants;
  • Mitigation and appraisal;
  • Automobile repairs and supplemental estimates; and
  • Total-loss automobile valuations.

The amendments also revise WAC 284-30-300 by removing the prior language limiting unfair claims settlement practices to violations occurring “with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice.” The OIC explains that this change aligns the regulation with Washington Supreme Court precedent recognizing that a single violation may constitute an unfair trade practice.

Why This Matters to Adjusters: Washington’s unfair claims settlement practices regulations establish minimum standards for claims handling. From a practical standpoint, adjusters should treat compliance with these requirements as an important part of claims handling. This includes clearly documenting each individual claim file with the investigation performed, information considered, communications with the claimant, and reasons supporting claim decisions.

Why Washington Changed the Rules: The OIC began examining the claims process following increased consumer complaints involving automobile and homeowners’ insurance. According to the OIC, a primary concern raised during its 2023 public process was the amount of time insurers were taking to address claims and make initial payment offers. The OIC expressly states that the rules are intended to improve communication, increase transparency, and require quicker claim investigations.

The OIC also identified the industry’s increasing use of artificial intelligence, photo-based adjusting, databases, and other technology in the claims process. The new regulations are intended to ensure that technological efficiencies do not replace an individualized and reasonable investigation of the claim. 

The Changes Adjusters Should Know

1. A “Reasonable Investigation” Requires More Than Software

One important amendment appears in WAC 284-30-330(4). The regulation continues to prohibit denying or refusing to pay all or part of a claim without conducting a reasonable investigation, but it now expressly provides that a reasonable investigation may not rely solely on the use of a database, including estimating software and benchmarks gathered from one or more databases. 

At the same time, WAC 284-30-320 now defines an “investigation” to include all activities related to determining liabilities under the available coverage and policy, including a reasonable assessment of:

  • Whether the particular claim or loss is covered;
  • The scope and value of loss or damage caused by an event; and
  • The reasonableness of costs or expenses incurred or expected for mitigation, treatment, repair, replacement, or recovery of covered loss or damage. 

Takeaway: Estimating software and databases can still be part of an investigation. However, the OIC explains that claims must be investigated individually using information beyond software or database outputs. 

2. The Clock Starts Earlier

Under the revised WAC 284-30-330(5), an insurer must affirm or deny coverage within a reasonable time after receiving “notification of a claim,” rather than after receiving fully completed proof of loss documentation. 

This distinction matters because “notification of claim” is broadly defined in WAC 284-30-320 to mean any notification, whether in writing or another method acceptable under the policy, that reasonably apprises the insurer or its agent of the facts pertinent to a claim. 

As will be discussed in Part Two of this series, related amendments impose more specific timelines calculated from notification of a claim. 

Takeaway: Do not assume claims handling deadlines begin only after a formal proof of loss arrives. The receipt of notification of the claim is now a critical date.

3. Avoid Repeated Requests for the Same Information

Under the amended WAC 284-30-330(11), it is an unfair claims settlement practice to delay an investigation or payment by requiring a claimant, a service or medical provider, or both to resubmit substantially the same information they have already provided. 

Takeaway: Before requesting additional information, review what is already in the file. If additional documentation really is necessary, the file and communication should make clear what remains outstanding.

4. Public Adjuster Involvement Cannot Change How a Claimant Is Treated

Under the amended WAC 284-30-330(14), an insurer may not unfairly treat a claimant differently because the claimant is represented by a public adjuster. It is an unfair claims settlement practice to fail to recognize a public adjuster as the legal representative of an insured or to timely provide requested information to the public adjuster or insured. 

Takeaway: The involvement of a public adjuster does not change the insurer’s obligation to handle the claim fairly. Claim decisions should continue to be grounded in the policy, facts, investigation, and documentation.

5. Mitigation Decisions Now Come with Specific Requirements

Amended WAC 284-30-330(20) and (21) establish requirements concerning a first-party claimant’s proposed scope of mitigation (Scope). First, where the insurer has a duty under the policy concerning mitigation, the rule requires the insurer to approve the claimant’s Scope or provide an approved Scope within five business days after receiving it. Second, to the extent the insurer rejects the claimant’s proposed Scope because it does not satisfy technical or industry standards, including a dollar itemization of the disapproved items, the insurer must disclose the reasons why. 

Takeaway: Mitigation proposals require prompt review and a sufficiently specific response within five business days of receiving the Scope where the insurer disagrees.

6. Appraisal Practices Also Receive New Attention

Under WAC 284-30-330(22), the amendment makes it an unfair practice to require an appraiser operating under the policy’s appraisal clause to adjust the appraiser’s actual cash value or loss valuation during the appraisal process. The provision does not prohibit the insurer from applying policy conditions to a completed appraisal award.

Takeaway: Where appraisal is contemplated, the claim file should clearly document the claim evaluation and settlement efforts preceding appraisal. 

What This Means for Adjusters

The common thread running through Washington’s amendments is an emphasis individualized investigation, transparency, prompt action, and clear documentation.  

For adjusters, four practices are particularly important: 

  1. Investigate: Do not rely solely on estimating software, databases, or benchmarks.
  2. Document: Make sure the claim file reflects the claim-specific information considered and the basis for the decision.
  3. Act Promptly: Treat notification of the claim as a critical date for claims-handling deadlines.
  4. Explain: When additional information is needed or the insurer disagrees with a claimed Scope, document what is needed and why.

This update is Part One of a three-part series on WAC changes. Part Two will address WAC 284-30-340, -360, -370, and -380, including some of the amendments with the greatest day-to-day impact on claim diary practices and claimant communications. 

For a complete overview of all amendments, see the Office of Insurance Commissioner’s Rule-Making Order.

For questions or guidance on how these updates may impact your organization, please do not hesitate to reach out to your GRSM attorney or a member of GRSM’s Insurance team for assistance.