Skip to main content
Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani, LLP. logo.

GRSM Prevails Before Nevada Supreme Court in Challenge to Personal Jurisdiction Ruling

Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani Partners Craig Mariam and Rachel Wise, together with Associate Paulyna Garcia, defeated a petition for writ of prohibition or mandamus in the Nevada Supreme Court, securing an out-of-state insurance broker’s right to pursue claims in Nevada against out-of-state defendants whose conduct was purposefully directed at the state and caused harm there.

The Nevada Supreme Court upheld the trial court’s finding that the insurance brokers made a prima facie showing of specific personal jurisdiction over the defendant company and its members, based on allegations that the defendants made material misrepresentations to, withheld material information from, or gave false information to the insurance brokers when applying for insurance coverage and later misused the litigation process against the insurance brokers, giving rise to claims for fraudulent and negligent misrepresentation, breach of contract and the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing, abuse of process, and declaratory relief. 

The Eighth Judicial District Court previously denied the defendants’ motion to dismiss, where GRSM successfully argued that the out-of-state defendants had purposefully reached into Nevada through their dealings and could not avoid a lawsuit merely by claiming they acted from beyond the state’s borders. Regarding the individual defendants, GRSM successfully established that the fiduciary shield doctrine does not insulate corporate agents from a court’s jurisdiction over claims arising from their own tortious conduct and that unrebutted evidence supported imputing contacts among the defendants. 

The Nevada Supreme Court denied the defendants’ petition, concluding that the Eighth Judicial District Court identified evidence supporting a prima facie showing of specific personal jurisdiction over all defendants, permitting the insurance brokers to pursue their claims in Nevada.